Article contents
How Much Room Does a Man Need? Spatial Confinement and Moral Agency in Crime and Punishment, The Dwarf, and The White Tiger
Abstract
Across a century and a half of urban modernity, Fyodor Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment (1866), Cho Se-hŭi's The Dwarf (1978), and Aravind Adiga's The White Tiger (2008) trace impoverished protagonists through rapidly and unevenly modernizing cities: Petersburg, Seoul, and Delhi. Scholarship on these texts has largely asked the question Dostoevsky stages in Razumikhin's quarrel with Porfiry: does an oppressive environment generate crime? This article reframes that controversy. Separating physical space, the structural constraints that turn it into a trap, and the symbols that register its meaning, the study reads the garret, the condemned house, the basement, and the car through Bachelard's vertical house, Bakhtin's threshold, and the world-literary frame of combined and uneven development, testing its reading against each novel's privileged characters. The novels yield three answers: in Dostoevsky space and psyche shape each other; in Cho the trap crushes bodies while the gentlest minds never waver from their gentleness; in Adiga consciousness darkens where darkness confronts the light from which it is excluded. Across all three, confinement is neither necessary nor sufficient for harm; it governs whether harm must trespass into another's space or can be done on ground of one's own, whom it reaches, and who bears its cost.
Article information
Journal
International Journal of Linguistics, Literature and Translation
Volume (Issue)
9 (11)
Pages
327-339
Published
Copyright
Copyright (c) 2026 Raees Unnisa
Open access

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Aims & scope
Call for Papers
Article Processing Charges
Publications Ethics
Google Scholar Citations
Publishing Packages