Article contents
University Students’ Engagement with Generative AI Feedback in L2 Writing: A Critical Review
Abstract
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) can support revision in second language writing, but improvements in a text do not by themselves establish learners’ understanding or learning. This critical narrative review synthesises 50 publications to examine how university students engage with GenAI feedback, how learner resources and instructional conditions relate to engagement, and what the evidence supports about revision and learning. Publications are distinguished by their use as direct empirical evidence, adjacent empirical evidence, or theoretical and review background. The synthesis indicates that uptake, rejection, follow-up questioning, and reflection require interpretation in relation to feedback quality, learners’ reasons, and their opportunities to act. Interaction records, self-reports, and revised texts provide complementary evidence, but none alone establishes the appropriateness of learners’ judgements. Positive experiences can coexist with difficulties in evaluating or implementing feedback. Teacher and tool support may redistribute the work of interpretation, verification, and revision, leaving different decisions to learners. Some studies assess unaided performance on new tasks or short-term retention of targeted language features, but evidence connecting specific engagement processes with subsequent learning remains limited. The review develops a feedback-event-oriented perspective that distinguishes process engagement, judgement appropriateness, and outcomes, while examining how judgement responsibilities are distributed among learners, teachers, and tools. This perspective supports comparisons across heterogeneous studies and motivates research linking specific feedback decisions to independently assessed revisions and subsequent unaided performance. Pedagogically, it suggests helping learners evaluate feedback through appropriate support, while retaining teachers’ and institutions’ responsibility for feedback conditions.
Article information
Journal
International Journal of Linguistics, Literature and Translation
Volume (Issue)
9 (11)
Pages
340-352
Published
Copyright
Open access

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Aims & scope
Call for Papers
Article Processing Charges
Publications Ethics
Google Scholar Citations
Publishing Packages